The U.S.
Government Needs Introspection
By T.S.
Khanna, February 14, 2023.
Looking at the
short history of the U.S. Government, it seems public panacea of one time can
become the poison of another time. Past
success can become the cause of future failure.
The unparalleled success of the American government founded on the Constitution
adopted in the late eighteenth century, now seems to be causing some obstruction
in the mental vision for the American future.
The Constitution
is still being looked at, studied, and interpreted too exclusively in parts on
principles, ignoring the experiences. This approach has restrained us from
evaluating the overall effectiveness of the Constitution.
Since the 1960s,
the performance level of the government seems to have lagged behind the new
challenges of changing times. It has
shown its inability to resolve certain issues that are now dividing the
American polity.
Take a look at
the issues Federal Government has been engaged in during the last several
decades. It has become a crucible of
repeated stalemates of inconclusive small quarrels, pumped up to the national
level: 1. Social spending and growing national deficit; 2. Out-of-control
border and illegal immigrants; 3. Free Trade v/s Protectionism, 4. Arms Control
for citizens; 5. Corporate taxes and Unions wages v/s losing American jobs to
other countries; and, 6. Abortion.
The indicated issues could be resolved by
common sense instead of divided debates.
However, in the absence of any adopted National Goals, these issues have
been rubbed on the American polity for too long, eroding the national
socio-political cohesion. Now these
issues have become like a skin disease with constant irritation and no
treatment in sight. Political groups
keep blaming each other for infection.
Government
introspection is too vast a subject to be covered in this short article; only
certain pointers are indicated for a quick glance.
1.
There
is no quality control of eligible and elected officials. There is a great gap between the skills
needed for campaigning by inciting/fooling the voters with fabricated facts and
the knowledge, character, integrity, and the spirit needed to perform the job;
2.
There
is no quality control of voters re their citizenship and knowledge of issues or
even the English language. This has
latent/silent adverse effect in the decision making processes of public
interest;
3.
Representative
Democracy, by its very nature, generates centrifugal forces in a polity that
keep splitting the society in the absence of some centripetal overpowering
force in place. Such a mechanism is not
provided in the Constitution;
4.
Phenomenal
growth of non-compromising parochial and special interests, with sufficient democratic
protection, keeps obstructing the positive governmental processes from maturing
in the public interest;
5.
Experience
has shown that democracy serves best under capitalistic economy in producing
wealth and benefitting the citizens with the least involvement of government. Yet, the government has adopted political
economy, abandoning the classic economics principles of open market
economy. This has caused a huge deficit. The Constitution has no provision to
safeguard the capitalistic economy and keep the government limited in size and
role;
6.
First
generation immigrants, without the knowledge of American history, politics,
demography, sociology of the American polity, national interests, and the feel
for the American culture get elected as public officials. Unknowingly, they disrupt the policies/plans
from jelling to serve the wider public interest. Citizenship by birth is a Constitutional requirement
only for the president’s position;
7.
The
firewall between the State and the Church, intended in the Constitution, is
violated by the government by taking over social welfare responsibility which
is the true jurisdiction of the religious institutions and social organizations. There is no provision in the Constitution to
correct this situation;
8.
President’s
position always carried a high level prestige to facilitate smooth performance
of duties. Congressional investigations
of the past few presidents have damaged the prestige. Congress itself operates under a very low
public prestige. The Constitutional
provisions are quiet about the subject;
9.
“Checks and Balances” design was intended for
a fair decision-making process. It is
backfiring under the government divided in two parties by creating frequent
log-jams in the decision making process;
10. Children’s morals are being shaped not so
much by humane religious influences as by the video games, where killing human
beings is only an incident, not a tragedy; and,
11. Individual liberty has been overemphasized at
the cost of ignoring moral, filial, and social obligations, essential for
bonding of society. This is yet another
reason that keeps splitting and disconnecting the people.